Rarity of godwits in Switzerland

For the third time ever, we saw a black-tailed godwit in Switzerland today. Reporting it, I was surprised to see that a black-tailed godwit in Switzerland ranks as a “rare” migrant, but seen regularly, while a bar-tailed godwit would be “very rare”. For 2019, ornitho.ch lists 489 sightings for black-tailed godwit, versus 186 sightings of bar-tailed godwit. (tbh, I find that difference not terribly significant, but I clearly won’t argue with ornitho rarity grades).

Black-tailed godwit

The black-tailed godwits spend the winter all over the place, from Australia to the Indian subcontinent and on to western Africa and even some areas in Europe. The Tagus estuary in Portugal is an important site for black-tailed godwit, currently threatened by plans to expand the nearby airport. It should be noted that subspecies tend to favor specific wintering grounds, islandica black-tailed godwits generally stay in Europe, anywhere between Scotland and Spain.

The “blackwits” feed in grassland and muddy estuaries. Their breeding habitat is fens, flood areas at the edge of large lakes, bogs and moorland. While they absolutely do visit coastal areas, they’re also comfortable on inland wetlands.

Black-tailed godwit in Argyll (Scotland), September 2018

The black-tailed godwit is the one with the white wing-bars, and long legs protruding beyond the tail.

Bar-tailed godwit

There are five subspecies of bar-tailed godwits, and their wintering grounds differ. In Europe, we get the lapponica subspecies, which spends the winter along the west coast of Europe and Africa, all the way to South Africa.

The “barwits” are rather specific with their diet, and feed mainly on bristle-worms, with a side-dish of bivalves and crustaceans. Bristle-worms are generally marine, and thus bar-tailed godwits are very much bound to coastal areas due to their diet.

Bar-tailed godwit in Aberdeenshire (Scotland) , January 2019

The bar-tailed godwit is the one without wing-bars, but with a longer, more prominent supercilium; the overall impression is similar to that of a curlew.

It’s the food, stupid

Sometimes it’s the migration route (scoters), sometimes the a species tends to migrate in one go rather than taking a break on neutral ground (black storks). In the case of the godwits, the bar-tailed godwit’s diet makes it a much more coastal bird, and thus much rarer in Switzerland than the more farmland-oriented black-tailed godwit.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s